Elemental Power- Ethics Study

 Nuclear Power- Ethics Analyze Essay

VALUE ISSUES IN DECISION-MAKING ABOUT

NUCLEAR POWER GENERATION:

AN ETHICAL RESEARCH

Report drawn up for Afrosearch

by

Prof. Johan Hattingh and Myself. Leanne Seeliger

Unit for Environmental Values

University of Stellenbosch

March 2002

you

Report about Value problems in decision-making about indivisible power technology. Final Version: 15 Drive 2002. Prepared for Afrosearch by the Device for Environmental Ethics, College or university of Stellenbosch. This Statement consists of 98 pages in total, including the Professional Summary, Bibliography and Addendas.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

BUSINESS SUMMARY ……………………………………………………………………….. 3

1 . INTRODUCTION …………………………………………………………………………….... …4

2 . METHODOLOGY ………………………………………………………………………….. ….... 6 3. THE BASIS AND FRAMEWORK OF THE TIPS ………………….. ……. 6

4. A HISTORICAL OVERVIEW OF THE EMERGENCE OF VALUE ISSUES ……….. ……11 LINKED TO NUCLEAR ELECTRIC POWER GENERATION

5. 1 The nuclear debate in the USA ………………………………. ……13 5. 2

The nuclear controversy in European Europe ……………………………21

4. a few

The indivisible debate in South Africa …………………………….. …25

5. THE ROOTS, PARAMETERS AND IDEOLOGICAL PERSONALITY OF THE SOCIOPOLITICAL DEBATE REGARDING NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY ……….. ………….. …………35 six. IDENTIFYING CORE ASSUMPTIONS AND VALUE PROBLEMS IN THE QUARRELS FOR AND AGAINST NUCLEAR ENERGY ……………………………………………. ……45 six. 1

A schematic overview ………………………………………………. 45 6. two

On the issue whether elemental power is clean or not …………52

6. 3

For the question if nuclear electrical power is safe or not ………….. 56

6th. 4

Indivisible energy and nuclear weapons …………………………….. sixty four

6. a few

On the issue whether elemental power can be affordable or perhaps not ……67

7.

CONCLUSION …………………………………………………………………………….. 69

8.

BIBLIOGRAPHY …………………………………………………………………………... seventy five

ADDENDUM 1: SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS …………………………….. 80 FOLLOWUP 2: FOCUSING ON VALUES IN PUBLIC PLACES DECISION-MAKING:

IMPORTANCE, METHODOLOGY AND VALUE ADDED ……………………………. 92 GLOSSARY…………………………………………………………………………………98

2

Record on Worth issues in decision-making about nuclear power generation. Final Version: 12-15 March 2002. Prepared intended for Afrosearch by Unit intended for Environmental Values, University of Stellenbosch. This Report consists of 98 internet pages in total, such as the Executive Overview, Bibliography and Addendas.

BUSINESS SUMMARY

This kind of report provides an overview with the value and ethical issues relevant to decision-making about elemental power era in general.

An historical summary of the beginning of these value issues as they respectively relevant to the USA, American Europe and South Africa was traced in Section 5.

Questions according to the ambivalence to nuclear electrical power generation (i. e. strong opposition versus strong support) that surfaced from this historical overview were analyzed in Section 5 and six, where we were holding placed within the context of a social-cultural as well as an examination of ideology. In this regard it absolutely was found that nuclear technology and technology has brought modernism to the peak, although exactly it has also raised problems that may not be overcome from within the construction of typical responses of modernism on its own.

Section 6 of this report has been devoted to a close examination of particular arguments pro- and en contra nuclear electrical power generation as they relate to value issues with regards to elemental power technology in general. Particular attention was given to problems of: §

Clean energy

§

Protection

§

Nuclear energy and nuclear weapons

§

The cost of nuclear energy.

The recommendations for decision-making that people make, have been completely based on the principles and articles of prevalent morality, the contours which are mentioned in Section 3. These recommendations happen to be stated in the report inside the context from where they have come about. All of these advice have been consolidated in a distinct list by the end of this record (see Sequela 1). It is important to note why these recommendations should be read along with one another, and...

References: almost 8

See the book by Daniel Ford, The Cult of the Atom (1982).

Related

 «Why performed Spinoza end writing his Ethics and commence work on his Theological-Political Treatise? » Dissertation

«Why performed Spinoza end writing his Ethics and commence work on his Theological-Political Treatise? » Dissertation

п»їInquiry Report (ROUGH DRAFT) 03/18/14 Jeffrey P. Rowan The question i have attained after very much reading is " For what reason did Spinoza stop publishing…...

 American Gods Essay

American Gods Essay

American Gods by Neil Gaiman pg. 307 yay Sam! There were silence as they crossed the bridge. " Who would kill all those…...

 Violino Protection Risk Mgmt Frameworks Composition

Violino Protection Risk Mgmt Frameworks Composition

п»ї Downloaded on May 5, 2010 from http://www.csoonline.com/article/592525/IT_risk_assessment_frameworks_real_world_experience?page=1 IT risk assessment frames: real-world encounter Formal risk assessment strategies try to consider guesswork out of assessing IT dangers.…...

 Water Container Ban Composition

Water Container Ban Composition

Plastic material water wine bottles are almost everywhere, from classes to malls. As a matter of fact, in the US alone, truck water wine bottles are consumed every second.…...

 commercial rules Essay

commercial rules Essay

Chapter 3 Commercial Regulation I. Basic Definitions a. Commercial Law-> It designates the whole body system of regulations & restrictions applicable to relations between persons involved in commerce, organization…...

 Good Parenting Research Paper

Good Parenting Research Paper

Great Parenting Parenting is indeed an entire time work, and there is hardly ever a perfect father or mother. There are judgments made by persons in today's contemporary…...

 Piercing the organization veil considering that the enactment with the New Companies Take action. Essay

Piercing the organization veil considering that the enactment with the New Companies Take action. Essay

Piercing the corporate veil because the enactment in the New Companies Act. 1 A company, as a separate entity, can be an acknowledged concept in South Photography equipment…...